Elegant St. Augustine Wedding at The Treasury on the Plaza

Christine and Christopher’s love story began in Boston in 2020 during the height of the pandemic. Both far from home—Christine had relocated from Florida for a new job, and Christopher was in town for his residency training—the two connected through Hinge. Their first date never happened after Christine had to cancel, and their second was cut short when Christopher was called into work. But the third date went off without a hitch, and they never looked back. As Christine puts it, “Thank God for those dating apps!”

Two years later, Christopher orchestrated a proposal so clever that Christine never saw it coming. For months, he had been “looking” for a particular vintage bar cart he claimed to have seen in a magazine. When he “found” one listed on Craigslist in southern Massachusetts, Christine, the curious one, double-checked the ad and helped message the seller back and forth. On the day of the “pick-up,” they arrived early and decided to take a walk along the waterfront. At sunset, in front of a picturesque lighthouse, Christopher proposed—with a friend capturing the moment and Christine’s mother flying in to witness it. The bar cart? Completely fabricated, with even the Craigslist messages written by Christopher himself.

For their Florida wedding, Christine and Christopher chose The Treasury on the Plaza in St. Augustine for its historic architecture and upscale elegance. As a wedding planner herself, Christine pulled inspiration from past events she had designed, but ultimately gave her vendors full artistic freedom to keep the day fresh, bright, and fun. The Grand Ballroom’s ornate columns and architectural details set the stage for a romantic ceremony, complete with indoor cold sparkler fountains for their first kiss. Both mothers presented the rings—a heartfelt gesture that gave the women who raised them a moment in the spotlight.

Christine wore the Aretta gown by Eva Lendel, complete with a detachable overskirt for a dramatic ceremony look that easily transitioned for dancing. “I wanted something different—nothing too bridal—and it was the first dress I tried on,” she recalls. The gown’s sleeves and subtle shimmer won her heart instantly. Christopher opted for a custom-tailored tuxedo from Suit Supply in Boston, choosing a modern fit for a classic look. Adding a personal touch, his pocket square was made from the same fabric as Christine’s gown.

The couple’s celebration was full of thoughtful design moments. A lush floral arch framed the ceremony and was later repurposed as a sweetheart table backdrop, illuminated by a neon sign of their last name. Their family built the seating chart from scratch—cutting wood, applying wallpaper, and adding vintage lighting for a one-of-a-kind display. A custom wedding logo was projected on the ballroom walls, while the cake, decorated with pressed dried florals, was set against a vintage bank vault from the venue’s original construction.

One of Christine and Christopher’s favorite decisions was doing a first look. This allowed them to finish all formal photos before the ceremony and spend 45 minutes of cocktail hour together, enjoying food, laughter, and connection. “We stayed on the dance floor all night, dancing with everyone we could and greeting guests together,” they shared. “Just seeing all the people we love in one place was our favorite memory—because when does that ever happen again?”

Christine and Christopher encourage engaged couples not to stress over the small stuff. “You hired professionals for a reason—trust them,” Christine advises. “The vibe of your night is based on you and your partner, so dance, have fun, and let loose.” Their wedding was a perfect balance of heartfelt moments, striking details, and joyful celebration—a reflection of their personalities and love story.